The TOPS Exchange Plan- 1500 Calories

nutritionist photo
Nutritionist Toby Amidor on
TOPS 1500 Calorie Plan

Toby Amidor, MS, RD is a registered dietitian with a master's degree in clinical nutrition and dietetics from New York University. She is also currently pursuing her doctoral degree in nutrition education from Teachers College, Columbia University.

Nutritionist Ratings
FPO
Bread, Pasta & Sweets (carbs)
in moderation
FPO
Red Meat
in moderation
FPO
Fruits & Vegetables
in moderation
FPO
Milk & Dairy
in moderation
FPO
Alcohol
almost never
FPO
Fast Weight Loss
nutritionist kind of agrees
FPO
Feeling Healthier
nutritionist strongly agrees
FPO
Simple Rules
nutritionist kind of agrees
FPO
Frequent Meals
nutritionist kind of agrees
FPO
Great Tasting Food
nutritionist agrees
FPO
Easy To Eat Out
nutritionist kind of agrees
FPO
Affordable
nutritionist agrees

A Nutritionist Weighs in...

The TOPS Exchange Plan consists of a well-balanced eating plan, exercise regimen, and motivational techniques that, if followed, should lead to the ultimate goal of a healthy lifestyle and weight loss. The meal plan encourages portion control and moderation. No food is forbidden per se, but many foods are limited in how much you can eat. The motivational techniques are based on theories that have shown success in weight loss for the long-term. These techniques are very useful, and if done correctly, should help motivate the dieter to success. The focus on weight loss and weight maintenance is essential for any long term success, and it?s nice to see a diet plan that actually gives equal time to both aspects of dieting.

If you wish to control your emotions and not let them get the best of you?

The TOPS Exchange Plan will work if followed correctly. However, you need to have time, motivation, control, and organizational skills for it to work. If you are looking for a quick and easy plan, this is not the answer. Meals and snacks need to be planned in advance. You will also need to be motivated in order to make lifestyle changes that will last forever. If you tend to stay on weight loss plans for only a few weeks and then feel that it is OK to stop, this is not the plan for you. The plan also addresses emotional eating and having control over food. These techniques are learned over time and not over a week or month. Lastly, to write in that journal on a daily basis, and list everything that you eat and drink, takes a lot of commitment. Journals are useful; however, you need to actually write in them.

Diet Pros Diet Cons
  • Well-balanced plan
  • Exercise guidelines are practical
  • Weight maintenance is just as important as weight loss
  • Encourages motivation strategies for long term success
  • Stresses a supportive environment
  • Well designed website with tons of helpful tools
  • Inexpensive to join (annual fee of $24 in U.S., $30 in Canada)
  • Must learn Exchange System and controlling portion sizes
  • Limited alcohol and caffeine
  • Daily journal entries are necessary

But, What Can I Eat?

See what's in & what's out

What do other members think about this diet?

Read Rants & Raves

Click Here

If you sell a healthy lifestyle product or service and want to advertise it here, we would love to hear from you.

If you're hawking a "magic" weight loss solution, we don't believe in that -- keep your money.

To learn more about advertising, please email: