Better Homes and Gardens® Weight Loss Plan

nutritionist photo
Nutritionist Toby Amidor on
Better Homes Diet

Toby Amidor, MS, RD is a registered dietitian with a master's degree in clinical nutrition and dietetics from New York University. She is also currently pursuing her doctoral degree in nutrition education from Teachers College, Columbia University.

Nutritionist Ratings
FPO
Bread, Pasta & Sweets (carbs)
in moderation
FPO
Red Meat
in moderation
FPO
Fruits & Vegetables
always
FPO
Milk & Dairy
in moderation
FPO
Alcohol
sometimes
FPO
Fast Weight Loss
nutritionist kind of agrees
FPO
Feeling Healthier
nutritionist agrees
FPO
Simple Rules
nutritionist kind of disagrees
FPO
Frequent Meals
nutritionist kind of agrees
FPO
Great Tasting Food
nutritionist agrees
FPO
Easy To Eat Out
nutritionist kind of disagrees
FPO
Affordable
nutritionist strongly agrees

A Nutritionist Weighs in...

If you take the time track what you are eating on the food log, learn the correct portion sizes, and stay your calorie limit, this plan can work – both short and long term. This is because you can adjust your calories while in the maintenance stage. Also, the online “Weight-Loss Planner” can keep you organized and positioned to succeed. One issue with the diet is that the USDA has updated their Food Guide Pyramid, but this plan still references the old Pyramid. Another issue is that unless you use the diet’s recipes and cook, there is not much guidance to help you follow the plan, nor are there enough sample meal plans. But the recipes sound enticing.

3.1 If you crave organization, this plan will keep you satisfied

Although this diet presents a healthy way to eat, some people may find it tedious and frustrating to track all the servings of the various food groups that they eat daily. However, on the free www.bhg.com website, you can have meal plans laid out for you, which can help you plan your grocery shopping and prepare meals.

This diet may also be more difficult if cooking isn’t your thing. Most of the book and website are filled with healthy recipes. For those who cook often, this is a great way to collect great tasting and diet friendly recipes. For those who don’t know how to turn on an oven, this plan may prove a bit more challenging. Also, those who eat out often must really learn serving sizes, as well as how to recognize if you’re eating the right number of servings of each food group. This may be hard to figure out if you rarely cook and aren’t sure what a tablespoon or cup looks like.

One great aspect of this diet is that it’s made for all different sizes and for both sexes. The calorie amounts, as well as the serving sizes, are individualized to your specific calorie needs. It’s also a very balanced plan in terms of getting foods from each food group.

 
Diet Pros
Diet Cons
  • Individualized plan for different body types and sexes
  • Increases knowledge of correct portions and serving sizes
  • Emphasizes importance of keeping a food log when dieting
  • Provides hundreds of healthy recipes
  • Stresses importance of emotional support by suggesting ways to involve others
  • Exercise promoted
  • Has free website one can join for more recipes, support, and a customized weight-loss plan
  • Allows most foods
  • Relies on counting food servings
  • Must learn appropriate portion sizes of different foods
  • Requires cooking
  • Time consuming to plan a day’s meals, although the “Weight-Loss Planner” makes this easier
  • Difficult for dieters who travel and eat out a lot
  • Whole grains are not emphasized
  • Uses the old Food Guide Pyramid

But, What Can I Eat?

See what's in & what's out

What do other members think about this diet?

Read Rants & Raves

Click Here

If you sell a healthy lifestyle product or service and want to advertise it here, we would love to hear from you.

If you're hawking a "magic" weight loss solution, we don't believe in that -- keep your money.

To learn more about advertising, please email: